A lot times when you hear that an artist is going to perform during a Super Bowl halftime show, we automatically assume the NFL is doing that artist a favor. Yes, that is true (in terms of exposure & future sales), but never forget the NFL greatly benefits as well in terms of ratings.
And it was a single episode of In Living Color that made it happen.
From the start of the first Super Bowl in the late 1960s until the early 1990s, Super Bowl halftime shows were centered around themes, tributes, and showcases. One year, the main song was: When the Saints Go Marching In. Chubby Checker, The Rockettes, and 88 grand pianos performed in 1988.
In essence, these Super Bowl halftime shows were very “family oriented”, “wholesome”, and “safe”. But it also tuned people off and were known to not be in tune with current mainstream culture.
It all came to a head in 1992:
The Winter Olympics were happening later that year, so the NFL decided to have a tribute called “Winter Magic” — and how dull a tribute it was (view at your own discretion):
Oh, there’s more:
A reported 79 million people tuned in to watch that year’s Super Bowl game. You think 79,000,000 folks were going to stay and watch that?
In Living Color to the rescue:
This very episode of In Living Color premiered during that year’s Super Bowl halftime by a rival network (Fox). The goal was for them to “counter-program” during the main halftime show (which was on CBS) — and they very successfully pulled it off. Check out the countdown they did right at the end.
A reported 10-20 million people saw this special (out of 79 million) — dropping that year’s halftime show broadcast by a whopping 22%.
The NFL countered in big way:
The NFL & CBS wasn’t going to go out without a fight, and they got none other than the King of Pop, Michael Jackson, to appear during the following year’s halftime show to perform some of his biggest hits.
For the first time ever, ratings for the Super Bowl halftime show exceeded the game itself. After that year, the NFL decided to use current pop stars performing their latest material during the halftime show, a format that still happens today.
Tell the whole truth:
So when people tell you the Super Bowl halftime show only helps the artist and that the artist should be grateful, tell them this story. Tell them there was a time Super Bowl halftime shows were mostly weak. Tell them an episode of In Living Color made the NFL change their ways because they lost huge ratings. Tell them they had to use a major pop star to get their ratings back.
And tell people the NFL Super Bowl halftime show needs the artist for ratings, just as much as the artist needs the NFL Super Bowl halftime show for exposure.
Vic Oyedeji is the founder of Unstripped Voice, and currently has a petition asking Maroon 5 to step down from the upcoming Super Bowl halftime show in solidarity with Colin Kaepernick, like Jay-Z, Rihanna, and Amy Schumer did. The petition has 68,000 signatures within 4 weeks as of this writing. Click here to sign.